2 A West Water Street

Sag Harbor, NY 11963

A 2023 four-level waterfront build in the historic core of Sag Harbor, with roughly 250 feet of harbor frontage and two 60-foot deep-water slips — the village address doing double duty as a marina. Inside are 12,400 sqft, eight bedroom suites and ten baths, capped by a rooftop pool and spa suspended over the harbor. At $34.99M and $2,822/sqft, the price is buying the frontage as much as the house; the real question is whether anything else on the water here even competes.